Which did you decide to go with? They're both awesome. But in retrospect, while I love the blue cloak on the other, I prefer the muted quality of the background on this. And the pink is in perfect contrast. There's more solemnity.
This is more to my liking. The brilliant colors in the previous rendition make for a wonderful display but I think the subdued background here gives her more life, makes her stand out better. She seems more divine this way.